Back to Play 10 Resources
Play 10: Hiring Screening

Structured Summary Format Template

Consistent format for hiring manager review: experience, credentials, engagement types, flags, fit score.

Structured Summary Format Template

Professional services firms waste hours per candidate on inconsistent screening notes. Partners can't compare candidates. Recruiters bury critical flags in paragraph-form emails. Hiring managers re-ask the same questions because no one documented the answers.

This template fixes that. It's a single-page format that captures everything a hiring decision-maker needs: verifiable credentials, project-level experience, billability fit, and deal-breaker flags. Use it for every candidate who passes initial phone screens.

The Six-Section Framework

Section 1: Candidate Snapshot

Full Name: [First Last]
Current Title: [Exact title from LinkedIn]
Current Employer: [Firm name + practice area if applicable]
Total Years Experience: [Number]
Years in Professional Services: [Number or "0 - corporate background"]
LinkedIn Profile: [URL]
Referral Source: [Job board / employee referral / recruiter name]

Why this matters: Hiring managers need context in 10 seconds. If someone has 12 years of experience but only 2 in professional services, that changes the conversation. Always include the LinkedIn URL so reviewers can verify claims without asking.

Section 2: Credentials (Verified Only)

Education:

  • [Degree], [Major], [University Name], [Graduation Year]
  • [Advanced Degree], [University Name], [Graduation Year]

Active Certifications:

  • [Certification Name] - [Issuing Body] - [Expiration Date if applicable]
  • [Certification Name] - [Issuing Body] - [Expiration Date if applicable]

Bar Admissions / CPA Licenses: [State(s), Year admitted, Status: Active/Inactive]

Do not include:

  • Degrees in progress unless graduation is within 90 days
  • Expired certifications
  • "Pursuing CPA" or similar aspirational statements

Verification note: For senior hires, confirm degrees through National Student Clearinghouse or equivalent. For licensed professionals (attorneys, CPAs), verify through state licensing boards before extending offers.

Section 3: Relevant Experience (Project-Level Detail)

List the 3-5 most relevant engagements or roles. Use this format for each:

[Project/Engagement Name or Client Type]

  • Role: [Title during this work]
  • Duration: [Months/Years]
  • Team Size: [Number of direct reports or team members]
  • Deliverables: [Specific outputs: financial model, compliance audit, M&A due diligence report]
  • Tools/Methodologies: [Software, frameworks, or methodologies used]
  • Billing/Revenue: [If known: billable hours, project value, realization rate]

Example:

Healthcare System Operational Assessment

  • Role: Senior Consultant
  • Duration: 6 months
  • Team Size: Led 3 analysts
  • Deliverables: 200-page operational assessment, 18-month implementation roadmap, board presentation deck
  • Tools/Methodologies: Lean Six Sigma, Tableau for data visualization, custom Excel financial models
  • Billing/Revenue: 850 billable hours, 92% realization rate

Why this format works: Generic bullet points like "managed client relationships" tell you nothing. This format shows whether someone can handle your firm's engagement types, team structures, and client expectations.

Section 4: Engagement Fit Analysis

Billable Role Readiness:

  • [ ] Can bill immediately as [Associate/Senior/Manager/Director]
  • [ ] Needs 30-60 day ramp period
  • [ ] Requires significant training before billable work

Delivery Model Experience:

  • [X] On-site client engagement (5+ years)
  • [X] Hybrid/remote delivery (2 years)
  • [ ] Managed services or retainer-based work
  • [ ] Expert witness or litigation support

Client-Facing Maturity:

  • [ ] Can lead client meetings independently
  • [ ] Can present to C-suite or board level
  • [ ] Needs supervision for client interactions
  • [ ] Limited client exposure (internal role background)

Practice Area Alignment:

  • Primary fit: [Tax / Audit / Advisory / Litigation Support / etc.]
  • Secondary fit: [Cross-selling opportunity or adjacent practice]
  • No fit: [Practices where experience doesn't transfer]

Utilization forecast: Based on current pipeline, this candidate could achieve [60% / 75% / 85%] utilization within [30/60/90] days.

Section 5: Red Flags and Development Gaps

Immediate Disqualifiers (if any):

  • Licensing issues (suspended CPA license, bar complaints)
  • Employment gaps >6 months with no explanation
  • Conflicted clients (currently serves competitors)
  • Non-compete restrictions that limit billability

Development Needs:

  • Technical: [Specific skills to build - e.g., "No experience with ASC 606 revenue recognition"]
  • Client management: [e.g., "Has not managed budgets >$500K"]
  • Industry knowledge: [e.g., "Zero healthcare sector experience"]
  • Tools/Systems: [e.g., "Never used Caseware or CCH Axcess"]

Cultural Fit Concerns:

  • [Note any concerns about work style, communication, or team dynamics based on interview observations]

Compensation Expectations vs. Budget:

  • Candidate's ask: $[Amount] base + [bonus structure]
  • Our range: $[Amount] base + [bonus structure]
  • Gap: [Within range / 10% over / 20%+ over - requires partner approval]

Section 6: Fit Score and Hiring Recommendation

Overall Fit Score: [1-5 scale]

  • 5 = Exceptional: Exceeds requirements, hire immediately
  • 4 = Strong: Meets all core requirements, minor gaps acceptable
  • 3 = Adequate: Meets minimum requirements, has development needs
  • 2 = Weak: Significant gaps, high risk
  • 1 = No Fit: Does not meet minimum requirements

Breakdown by Category:

  • Technical skills: [1-5]
  • Client readiness: [1-5]
  • Cultural fit: [1-5]
  • Billability potential: [1-5]

Recommendation: [HIRE / PASS / HOLD FOR FUTURE ROLE]

Rationale (2-3 sentences):
[Specific reason for recommendation. Example: "Candidate has 8 years of Big 4 audit experience with 6 healthcare clients, directly matching our Q2 pipeline needs. Compensation expectations align with our Senior Manager range. Recommend extending offer with 90-day technical training plan for new revenue recognition standards."]

Next Steps:

  • [ ] Schedule partner interview
  • [ ] Conduct reference checks (need 3 professional references)
  • [ ] Verify CPA license status
  • [ ] Prepare offer letter at $[Amount] base

Blank Template (Copy-Paste Ready)

### Candidate Snapshot
**Full Name:**  
**Current Title:**  
**Current Employer:**  
**Total Years Experience:**  
**Years in Professional Services:**  
**LinkedIn Profile:**  
**Referral Source:**

### Credentials
**Education:**  
- 

**Active Certifications:**  
- 

**Bar Admissions / CPA Licenses:**  

### Relevant Experience
**[Project/Engagement Name]**  
- **Role:**  
- **Duration:**  
- **Team Size:**  
- **Deliverables:**  
- **Tools/Methodologies:**  
- **Billing/Revenue:**

**[Project/Engagement Name]**  
- **Role:**  
- **Duration:**  
- **Team Size:**  
- **Deliverables:**  
- **Tools/Methodologies:**  
- **Billing/Revenue:**

**[Project/Engagement Name]**  
- **Role:**  
- **Duration:**  
- **Team Size:**  
- **Deliverables:**  
- **Tools/Methodologies:**  
- **Billing/Revenue:**

### Engagement Fit Analysis
**Billable Role Readiness:**  
- [ ] Can bill immediately as [Level]  
- [ ] Needs 30-60 day ramp period  
- [ ] Requires significant training before billable work

**Delivery Model Experience:**  
- [ ] On-site client engagement  
- [ ] Hybrid/remote delivery  
- [ ] Managed services or retainer-based work  
- [ ] Expert witness or litigation support

**Client-Facing Maturity:**  
- [ ] Can lead client meetings independently  
- [ ] Can present to C-suite or board level  
- [ ] Needs supervision for client interactions  
- [ ] Limited client exposure

**Practice Area Alignment:**  
- **Primary fit:**  
- **Secondary fit:**  
- **No fit:**

**Utilization forecast:**

### Red Flags and Development Gaps
**Immediate Disqualifiers:**  
- 

**Development Needs:**  
- **Technical:**  
- **Client management:**  
- **Industry knowledge:**  
- **Tools/Systems:**

**Cultural Fit Concerns:**  
- 

**Compensation Expectations vs. Budget:**  
- **Candidate's ask:**  
- **Our range:**  
- **Gap:**

### Fit Score and Hiring Recommendation
**Overall Fit Score:** [1-5]

**Breakdown by Category:**  
- Technical skills:  
- Client readiness:  
- Cultural fit:  
- Billability potential:

**Recommendation:** [HIRE / PASS / HOLD]

**Rationale:**  


**Next Steps:**  
- [ ]  
- [ ]  
- [ ]

Implementation Rules

Who completes this: The recruiter or HR coordinator fills Sections 1-3 after the phone screen. The hiring manager completes Sections 4-6 after the technical interview.

When to use it: For every candidate who advances past the initial 30-minute phone screen. Do not create summaries for candidates who don't meet minimum qualifications.

Where to store it: Save as [LastName_FirstName]_Summary_[Date].pdf in your ATS or shared hiring folder. Never store in personal email.

Review cadence: Hiring managers should review all summaries within 48 hours of receipt. Partners review only candidates scored 4 or 5.

Retention policy: Keep summaries for hired candidates in their personnel file. Delete summaries for rejected candidates after 12 months per EEOC guidelines.

This template eliminates the "I need to re-read their resume" problem. It turns hiring decisions from gut feelings into documented, defensible evaluations.

Revenue Institute

Reviewed by Revenue Institute

This guide is actively maintained and reviewed by the implementation experts at Revenue Institute. As the creators of The AI Workforce Playbook, we test and deploy these exact frameworks for professional services firms scaling without new headcount.

Revenue Institute

Need help turning this guide into reality? Revenue Institute builds and implements the AI workforce for professional services firms.

RevenueInstitute.com